Myths versus facts
Twelve mix-ups, carefully untangled
12 common mix-ups, answered from official wording, without blending measurements or names that the official pages themselves keep distinct.
Myth. Smilodon was a sabre-toothed tiger, closely related to living tigers.
Fact. Official NPS wording: “Though sometimes called a “saber-toothed tiger”, Smilodon is not directly related to tigers or other pantherine cats such as lions, leopards, and jaguars.”[source]
Myth. All sabre-tooths were one closely related group.
Fact. An official NHM page says they “are not a single closely related group of animals,” but a number of groups “spanning millions of years.”[source]
Myth. The official 11-inch and 28-centimetre canine figures are the same measurement, so they can be used interchangeably.
Fact. The NPS 11-inch figure is given for S. fatalis. The NHM 28-centimetre figure is not tied to a named species on that page. This site keeps them apart.[source][source]
Myth. There is one official extinction date for Smilodon.
Fact. NPS wording: both species “went extinct roughly 10,000 years ago.” An NHM page gives a range ending “12,000 years ago.” Both are kept.[source][source]
Myth. A Nebraska mount labelled Smilodon californicus can silently be called S. fatalis.
Fact. The file and historic name is Smilodon californicus (Bovard, 1907). This site does not silently relabel it.
Myth. A Paris skeleton on this site can be given a species name for convenience.
Fact. The file does not name the species. This site does not invent one.
Myth. Healed injuries prove that Smilodon lived in lion-like prides.
Fact. Official wording is a suggestion: healed injuries “have led some paleontologist to suggest that they had some form of social structure that shared resources.” Groups “could have been similar to African lion prides or perhaps monogamous pairs with offspring.”[source]
Myth. S. gracilis was as large and robust as S. fatalis.
Fact. Official wording: S. gracilis “lived 2.5 million years ago and was a smaller and less robust species.”[source]
Myth. S. populator is just another name for S. fatalis.
Fact. Official wording treats them as two species after the crossing of the Isthmus of Panama: North American S. fatalis, and “the larger South American Smilodon populator.”[source]
Myth. The 1845 date on a Lund mandible is the official naming year.
Fact. The file says the mandible was collected by Peter W. Lund in Brazil in 1845. Official NPS wording says the species was named in 1842. Both dates stay with their sources.[source]
Myth. Smilodon was the largest extinct cat at Tule Springs.
Fact. Official wording: it was “the second largest extinct cat at Tule Springs.” The American lion, Panthera atrox, is described on the same page as the largest extinct cat in Pleistocene North America.[source]
Myth. If it looks like a tiger in a film, official pages treat it as a tiger.
Fact. Official NPS wording is the opposite. The popular name appears, and is then refused: Smilodon “is not directly related to tigers.”[source]
Enjoyed this sabre-tooth desk?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next fossils.im site get built.